I know people are going to be mad at how often Ryle shows up here but that’s the reality of how abusive situations are, they don’t just die or leave you alone— colleen did a fantastic job at showing how realistic this situation is, at how much of a gaslighter he is.

Otherwise, Song’s narration is understated and contemplative as Lily pieces together her past and present feelings about Atlas. it just feels like she is monetizing off the weird success it ends with us got on booktok, and it definitely reads like a cash grab as well.This first edition hardcover novel is a must-have for adult readers who enjoy modern and contemporary romance genres. Read more about the condition New: A new, unread, unused book in perfect condition with no missing or damaged pages.

Women don’t always have a Prince Charming waiting for them after they escape an abusive relationship. It Starts with Us [Hardcover], It Ends with Us 2 Books Collection Set By Colleen Hoover book is in low demand now as the rank for the book is 300,082 at the moment. Lily and her ex-husband, Ryle, have just settled into a civil co-parenting rhythm when she suddenly bumps into her first love, Atlas, again. Colleen Hoover tells fan favourite Atlas’s side of the story and shares what comes next in this long-anticipated sequel to It Ends with Us. It shows how realistic, how tragic and how even a happily ever after is still shadowed by the ache and reminder of abuse.

speaking of plot points manufactured to make lily and atlas seem like they had more in common: the brother thing came out of fucking nowhere. For the Ryle apologist and stans: I’m so glad Colleen wrote this book because there’s NO room for y’all’s bullshit. speaking of: stop writing her letters for the love of god i literally don’t know if my heart is cold and dead but we get it atlas, you love her and can’t live without her and she saved you. Lily hasn’t always had it easy, but that’s never stopped her from working hard for the life she wants.